When Does Limited Liability Not Hold?
  • Disclosure of Value
    • when the innkeeper agrees in writing to assume liability for a greater $ amount
  • Equitable Estoppel
    • a legal principle that precludes a person from claiming a right or benefit because that person made a false representation to another who relied on that information to his or her detriment
  • When the Hotel is Negligent
    • comparative negligence can apply where appropriate
    • in Nevada, innkeepers are protected by the limiting statutes even if they are grossly negligent
Liability During Check-in and Check-out
  • Guest Status
    • most state limiting statutes apply only to "guests"
  • Liability After Check-out
    • a patron maintains the status of a "guest" for a reasonable amount of time after check-out
  • Bailment  ==>  a transfer of possession of personal property from one person to another with the understanding that the property will be returned
  • Bailor  ==>  person giving possession of the property
  • Bailee  ==>  person receiving possession of the property
  • 4 Essential Elements of a Bailment
    • personal property  --  moveable, tangible objects
    • delivery of possession
    • acceptance of possession by the bailee
    • bailment agreement  --  expressed or implied
  • Affect of Bailment on Liability
    • no bailment implies no liability
    • if bailment exists the bailee is not automatically liable
      • liability depends on whether or not the bailee exercised reasonable care
      • the amount of care is determined by the type of bailment
  • 3 Types of Bailments
    • Sole Benefit of the Bailor
      • need to exercise only a slight degree of care
    • Sole Benefit of the Bailee
      • need to exercise a very high degree of care
    • Mutual-Benefit Bailment
      • also called a bailment for hire
      • need to exercise ordinary care
      • bailor must warn bailee of any defects in the property  ==>  strict liability
  • Proof in Bailment Cases
    • bailor often has difficulty in proving that the bailee failed to exercise the required amount of care
    • as a result, bailor only needs to prove 3 things...
      • delivery of the property
      • acceptance of the property by the bailee
      • failure to return property or returned property damaged
    • these 3 facts establish a prima facie case
      • i.e., a case sufficient to warrant a judgment for the plaintiff if the defendant does not contradict it with other evidence
  • What about items inside of the bailed property?
    • no liability unless the bailee is informed of the item's existence
    • informed if  ==>  bailor tells bailee about the item or if the item is in plain view
  • Rules Particular for Bailment of Cars
    • must leave keys for bailment to exist
    • limiting statutes do not apply to cars
    • disclaimers of liability on signs and receipts are not effective for limiting liability for loss or damage
Liability in Checkrooms
  • the general basis for liability is bailment
  • constructive bailment  ==>  a bailment created by law; must exercise reasonable care
  • bailment exists when the bailor gives proof of receipt of the property
  • many states limit liability in checkrooms  --  (e.g., in NY limit is $200)
  • if checkroom is unattended then usually no bailment thus no liability

back to the top of this page
back to the Hospitality Law and Ethics Home Page
back to Professor Fisher's Home Page

this page is maintained by Reed Fisher
last updated January 15, 2011